We Are With You
Every Step Of The Way
Photo of Keith Friley and Fritz H Dugas
Photo of Keith Friley and Fritz H Dugas

What factors do judges consider when determining child custody?

It is often difficult to navigate the emotional turmoil during child custody disputes. However, it is important to get these arrangements right for the benefit of the children.

With that in mind, family court judges consider key factors before arriving at a decision.

Each parent’s ability to care for the child’s physical needs

A foundational consideration is the child’s need for adequate food, clothing and health care. A stable home is also important.

The judge will assess the living conditions of each parent’s home and their ability to maintain a safe and healthy environment. They will also consider each parent’s ability to provide for unique daily needs, such as specific medical or dietary requirements.

The capacity to address emotional and mental needs

Beyond physical needs, the judge will evaluate how well each parent can address the child’s emotional, mental, moral and spiritual development. Emotional stability and mental health support are vital for a child’s well-being.

The judge will look at each parent’s involvement in the child’s education, extracurricular activities and social life. Moral guidance and values play a role too, as does the ability to foster a supportive and nurturing environment.

For some families, worship may be a significant element in the child’s life. The judge will take into account how each parent supports the child’s religious or spiritual practices.

Environmental stability and social support

The child’s current environment and social support system are also key considerations. The judge will examine how long the child has lived in the current home and community.

The judge will consider the impact of potentially moving away from familiar surroundings, including schools, friends and extended family members. Disrupting these connections can be challenging for a child and create mental or emotional distress. Therefore, the judge will weigh these factors carefully.

The child’s preference and bond with a parent

In some cases, the judge will consider the child’s preference, especially if the child is older and more mature. The judge may observe evidence of interactions and speak directly with the child to understand their feelings. A strong, positive relationship with both parents is ideal, but the judge will prioritize the child’s overall happiness and security.

There is no fixed rule for how courts decide child custody cases. The outcome depends on the specifics of each case and the judge’s discretion. Whether a parent gets their preferred arrangement depends on how well they present their case to meet their child’s needs.